
Archibald Campbell was a political officer at Darjeeling in N. India at the time of Joseph Hooker’s celebrated 1849 visit to the Himalaya, which he helped to expedite. He was perhaps fortunate to have the most spectacular flowering tree yet discovered – the pink type species of Magnolia campbellii – named for him by Hooker. For Hooker’s early experience of the species was restricted to Darjeeling and Sikkim, where the superb pink form is local, and of very limited distribution, possibly even ex situ as planted specimens: as Polunin and Stainton say in their 1984 Flowers of the Himalaya ‘A pink-flowered form is cultivated around Darjeeling’. By contrast, the white form (now M. campbelli alba) is ubiquitous across wide swathes of the Himalaya, from Nepal to Tibet. For the pink form to have been recognised as the type of the species is arguably an accident of history.

Kingdon Ward’s well known description of M. campbellii in Sikkim refers to ‘a fleet of pink waterlilies riding at anchor in a green surf’. But he also described the trees in Sikkim as white-flowered and rarely pink, writing ‘[we] gaze down in wonder on the dark forest, lit by thousands of milk-white glowing cups, hung like beacons in the bare trees, and be silent.’

Hooker himself mentioned the scarcity of the pink form in 1855, only six years after first seeing it and naming it – due to the demand, he suggested at the time, for its high quality timber from huge specimens, up to 150ft tall.
But all other published descriptions I have read of M. campbellii in the wild are of a white, not pink, form of the species. Polunin and Stainton state that there are no pink forms in Nepal. In 1936 Sherriff and Hicks described the species as up to 80ft in central Bhutan: ‘and a very fine sight indeed in full bloom (cream) and very common’. And a year later in 1937, Ludlow and Sherriff in N. Bhutan saw M. campbellii ‘in magnificent flower, forming a vivid white streak along the hillside’.

Heading west they encountered ‘many trees of the huge white-flowered Magnolia campbellii around 100ft tall’.

In 1989, travelling for almost 3 weeks in West and Central Bhutan, when M. campbellii was in its full pomp, with scores of trees in full flower, I never saw a single pink form.

Long before Hooker described the pink form, William Griffith, an assistant surgeon working in Madras for the East india Company, had travelled extensively in Assam, Burma, Bhutan and neighbouring countries, and made significant collections. He discovered the white form in 1838, eleven years before Hooker saw the pink form. Griffith described the white form in his diaries, but alas, died at the untimely age of 35, and his records were published posthumously, well after Hooker had already published his description of the pink form and designated it the type species.

But for this accident of history, the white form would certainly have been described as the type species, and the pink form a local forma rosea.
The white form in the wild is long lived, and can grow to a great size with specimens up to 150 ft reported, and once established, is seemingly indestructible.

The tree on the left is at the head of a village called Gante Gompa in Bhutan, growing in the precinct of a temple. Completely exposed and coppiced by storm and hollow, it is still 70ft tall and 8ft in diameter, full of vigour and reportedly flowering to capacity. The middle picture is a very old specimen, a true plant of M. campbellii alba from the Himalaya, planted on Zixishan, a temple mountain between Kunming and Dali in Yunnan, apparently presented to celebrate the historic visit of a significant religious figure. This makes sense, as these pure white flowers were regarded as a symbol of purity among Buddhists. It is protected by a monk, who as someone pointed out, has not done a good job as it has been burned, hollowed out and hacked, but in spite of it all still manages to grow with vigour, and flower freely. On a subsequent visit the guardian allowed me to climb it to photograph the flowers close up (right) which confirmed it as classical M. campbellii alba.
Further improbably tough hostile conditions are evidenced in a M. campbellii alba not far from us at White House Farm in Kent. “Plant a tree in seventy three” was a slogan to encourage schoolchildren in the UK to plant trees. The late Brian Doe, then Head Gardener at Borde Hill in Sussex took a seedling of M. campbellii alba to the field of a friend who lived on the North Downs on chalk, next to a chalk quarry, and it flowered with a classic cup-and-saucer pure white campbellii bloom. It survives, if not prospers.

I’ve no idea why to Brian it seemed a suitable place for a magnolia, which in the wild enjoys an acid forest soil with plentiful moisture in the benign shelter of open woodland. Maybe it was a deliberate experiment. It rather echoes the work and experience of Colin Mugridge, who grows healthy rhododendrons in a limestone quarry in N Wales with a pH of 7-4. Here it was planted in turf, short cropped by grazing sheep, on a south facing slope, in full sun, in the precinct of a cottage called Chalk Pit Cottage. The soil is grey, full of shards of crushed chalk, and with little humus. At one stage the tree had a pony tethered to it. There could be nowhere more hostile, but although growth was not optimal, it evidently showed no signs of chlorosis.
Who claimed that these Magnolias required an acid or neutral soil, or were impossible to grow in alkaline conditions? Has any formal research been done into soil pH? Does this single example open this whole question? If any reader of this blog has further experience of alkalinity tolerance in magnolias, please comment below, or email us at whitehousefarmarb@gmail.com. All the books say don’t plant these trees in alkaline conditions, so this is an important issue. Would there were more Brian Does who dared to defy received wisdom.
In the wild, the pink form may be local, the white form ubiquitous: but what is also curious about this brilliant species is that yellow forms reportedly exist quite widely in Bhutan, and must have been encountered, but for some reason not reported, by earlier explorers.

I saw this inaccessible specimen deep in the forest, but even with a zoom camera was unable to do it full justice. A student from Bhutan at Wisley told me that yellow-flowered specimens are quite frequent off the beaten track, and not at all unusual. Peter Cox sent me a photo of fallen tepals from a yellow form he saw in NE India.


At Mt Congreve in Ireland this fine specimen shows that this is not a flight of wishful thinking, but a reality. The yellow is quite intense in the bud, gradually fading with maturity to cream. It is surprising that this opportunity for hybridisers has not been exploited. A cross with M. acuminata or one of its hybrids seems obvious.
It is easy to conclude that these are straightforward, forgiving plants, and once established, indestructible, combining this cultural toughness with a generosity of flower of a beauty unsurpassed by any other flowering tree. But hang on a minute, comes the cry – in the UK they flower in March, and thus the flowers are always susceptible to frost damage.
But this is ‘up to a point, Lord Copper’ – siting with tree top cover, or against a wall, with tree top cover, or on a slope to guarantee cold air drainage, can each contribute to mitigate this. At White House Farm on our katabatically favourable hill in Kent, we have suffered frost damage to our campbelliis only once in the last 15 years. Perhaps climate change brings such hidden advantages.
M. campbellii is also said to take 20-30 years to flower from seed. This may be true in the benign west country, where rainfall and shaded warmth stimulate impressive growth, perhaps at the expense of flower, but I have found they will flower from a strong graft at 10-12 years with good light and good siting. Perhaps it is time for us all – even those in their wrinkly sixties – to give this wonderful tree a try, and experience the skin tingling majesty of its flowers.
By Maurice Foster
- Some of these ideas and images were shared at an IDS Study Day on Magnolias held at Arboretum Wespelaar, on April 14th 2024.




















































































